Äîêóìåíò âçÿò èç êýøà ïîèñêîâîé ìàøèíû. Àäðåñ îðèãèíàëüíîãî äîêóìåíòà : http://www.mccme.ru/free-books/bibliometric.pdf Äàòà èçìåíåíèÿ: Thu Apr 21 11:37:15 2011 Äàòà èíäåêñèðîâàíèÿ: Tue Oct 2 00:48:42 2012 Êîäèðîâêà: IBM-866 Ïîèñêîâûå ñëîâà: http www.badastronomy.com bad tv foxapollo.html

,
(c )






.



, (c ). íí .: , . íí .: . ISBN -- , , . , , - . ë ¨, . .



.

http://www.mccme.ru/free- books/bibliometric.pdf

ISBN

--

-

-



. . . . . . . . . . . . . , . , . . . . . . . . . : . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . - . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . , . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ë¨ . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .



, IMU-Net. (IMU) ë ¨, . IMU-Net ( .) ë ¨. - , . , (ICIAM) (IMS). : í (, ), , IMU; í (, ), IMS; í (, ), ICIAM. , , http://www.mathunion.org/Publications/2007/ChargeComOnQuantAssessmRes070521.pdf
: IMU-Net b: June , http://www.mathunion.org/imu- net/archive/2008/ imu- net- 29b/. , ë ¨ íí , - , . , . . , -, ISI (Institute of Science Information. . . íí . .) , - . . , ISI-- . . , ISI-- - , , , , . . , . . , . . , - , , , . .


, , , . , , IMU, ICIAM IMS, . ë ¨ . : http://www.mathunion. org/Publications/Report/CitationStatistics. . íí IMU, , , - , ( ), , . IMU IMU-Net , , , , . IMU, ICIAM IMS , , , , . , , /, , ë ¨. , , , , , . , . , IMU


. . ., . íí

. íí . .



, ,
(IMU) (ICIAM) (IMS) . , ë ¨ . ë ¨ , . , , , , , , . . § , . , . , . § ë¨, . , . , , , . § , íí , , , . . . : http://www.mathunion.org/fileadmin/ IMU/Report/CitationStatistics.pdf. . . .


. , . íí , , , . , , . § -. , . . , , - . - íí , . § , , , - , . , - . ! , , . § . , , . h-, , , . h- , . , , . , - h-, , . -


. , . , . ë¨. , , ë¨. , , . : . , , . , , , , . , . , , , , , , . , , , .
, (Technion) (), ,

ë ¨, , ; ( ), , , , . , ë ¨, íí .





. , , , íí . . , , ; , , . : . , ë ¨ () , , . :
ë , , íí UK Research Assessment Exercise (RAE). , , , ( )¨ [Evidence Report , . ].

, , , , . , , . , (= ) . , , íí , , , íí , .


. , . , . , . § -, . , , . . (, -), , , . § -, , , . . , , , , íí ë¨ (). , , . § -, , , . , . , , . íí . , , , , ë ¨ , . , , , . , , , , , , . , , , ,


, . , , ë¨. ë ?¨ , : ë !¨ , - , , - , , (., , [Martin ] . [CareyííCowlingííTaylor ]). , . , , . . , -. ( , ; , , , .) , . , . , ë¨ , , . ( íí ), , . -, . , , íí . , , , , . , , ,


. , . , . , . - , , , . , , , , . , . ; . . , ( ) , . , . , , , , , . ë , ¨, íí . 1) .

: -

2)

- - [Garfield ]. , Thomson Scientific ( ) Journal Citation Reports. Thomson Scientific 9 000 , [THOMSON: SELECTION]. , , , , . (, Thomson Scientific -


, Mathematical Reviews Zentralblatt, . 3) ) - , , , ( , Thomson Scientific). - 1,5 , , , , 1,5 , . Thomson Scientific - , [THOMSON: SELECTION]. , -, .
ë- , , , , . , ¨ [THOMSON: IMPACT FACTOR].

, , , . - . (. [Seglen ], [AminííMabe ], [Monastersky ], [Ewing ], [Adler ] [Hall ].) (i) - . , , -. , , , . , - íí . ë¨ , -


. , . , . . , , . (ii) , , , [Garfield ]. , , , . , , . 3 ( Math. Reviews), , 90 % . , - 10 % . 4)

, , . , íí , íí , -, -. Thomson Scientific.

- ? . Thomson Scientific -, , , ( ) - [Garfield ]. Math. Reviews, ë-¨ (. . 1 ) -


, 2, 5 10 . , 5- 10- - 2- -. 100

ë-¨ 2, 5 10 100 . Math. Reviews.

, . , , - . , ë ¨ - , , , , , - ë ¨ (. ). (iii) - [AminííMabe ]. (ii): , - . , - , . ( , .) , , -


. , . , . -, , .

, , . Thomson Scientific [AminííMabe ].

(iv) - , , , [AminííMabe ]. , , 50 , - 50 %. , , , . , , . (v) , , , , , ‡ ( ) . - , . , , , , , , , , , -


( ) - [AminííMabe ]. (vi) - , . - , , , - ë¨. ‡ - íí - . , ( ), , . ( , ) , , . - ? ? -? (. .) , , , , , -. - , , , . , - , . - . , - , , - . , -, , , . , - , , , ,


. , . , . , . , , . , ( ). , , . - - . Thomson Scientific, ( ) , -:
ë Thomson Scientific -, . - , , . - ¨ [THOMSON: IMPACT FACTOR].

, .


- , , . : - , , . ; . , . - , , ë ¨ ë ë¨ (national) () . íí . .


¨. : , ( ) , , . , - ( ). Thomson Scientific :
ë, - . - , ¨. [THOMSON: IMPACT FACTOR]

, ( ). . Science Citation Index Core. -. 30 , . 667 , 21 . ; íí . 15 ; Thomson Scientific 10 . . . . . , . 3 , Thomson Scientific, 2 , , 1 , ( -).


. , . , . . , ( ), - , . . , , -, , , : - A , B, , , A B, A . . , ([Seglen ], [Garfield ]). . Proceedings of the American Mathematical Society íí . Proceedings , , . 2381 ( 15 000 ). Math. Reviews ( -) 0,434. Proceedings of the AMS

Transactions of the AMS , , , , , Proceedings. -


Transactions 1165 ( 25 000 ), 0 12. 0,846, , Proceedings. Transactions of the AMS

, Proceedings, íí Transactions. , ‡ ‡ o - ( o!). ? Transactions of the AMS Proceedings? , Transactions ( ) Proceedings, , : , ? , Proceedings , Transactions? 62 %. , 62 % , Proceedings Transactions, - Proceedings - Transactions! , , . ,


. , . , . , - ( ) 5) . . ; - . (, Journal of the AMS - 2,63, , Proceedings. 32 % Proceedings Journal.) , , - , . , , - . , , - ( ) , , , . . - , - , , , , . -, , , . , , . - , , . - , , .





- íí , , , . , . h-: h- n, n , n . . . E. [Hirsch ] , ë¨ . , . m-: m- h- , . . , , . g -: g - n, n n2 . [Egghe ]. h- , n . g - . , . , ([BatistaííCampiteliííKinouchiííMartinez ], [BatistaííCampiteliííKinouchi ], [SidiropoulsííKatsarosííManolopoulos ]). , h- ë , , ¨ [Hirsch , . ]. , ë , , ¨.


. , . , . . , h- , h- , (, , ). , , , h-. , , h-. , , , h-. , h-. , h- :
ë , , h, , . , ( ) h- , h , , ¨ [Hirsch , . ].

. ( , 10 10 , 90 , 9 . , , 10 , 10 , íí 10 , 100 . - ?) 6) h-, , ëh- , ...¨ [Hirsch , . ], ë¨, , ë ¨. , . ë ¨, . . ,


h- , . , íí . h- [LehmannííLacksonííLautrup ] , h- ( , m-) ë¨, . , , ë¨. [LehmannííJacksonííLautrup ] h- , . - , h-, , - - . , ([BatistaííCampitelliíí Kinouchi ], [MolinanííMolinan ]). , h- [Kinney ]. íí . , , , . , , . , , , . h- , . , . , , ; , , , .


. , . , .


, , : ? , , , , ë¨. , , . , , , .
ë, , . , , , , , . (. . , ) ¨. [THOMSON: HISTORY] ë , , , , ( ) ¨ [LehmanííJacksonííLautrup , . ]. ë , ...¨ [Garfield , . ]. ë , , - ¨. [Garfield , . ] ë íí ¨ [THOMSON: FIFT Y YEARS].

íí ë¨, ë¨, ë¨, ë ¨. ë¨ , - . , -


. , . :
ë , [Garfield , . , , . . -"¨ " ]

, , , ë-¨, ë ¨, , ë¨ , . . , . , , , , . , :
ë , , . ... , , , ...¨ [MartinííIr vine , c. ].

[Cozzens ] , íí ë¨ ë¨. , , - , , íí - , , - ë¨, ë ¨ . . : , - , , . ë¨


. , . , . , . , . , ë¨ . . (, Math. Reviews 3 30 % , .) ? ë¨ , , , , , ë¨, : ( ë¨), , ( , , ?), , , . ë¨ . ë¨ , , ë , , , , , ¨ [Brooks ]. . - ë¨, , . ë¨ , . ë ¨ . , . , , , ë¨, . , , , -


, (, ). , Evidence , ( ) - :
ë , , , ¨ [Evidence Report , . ].

, , , , , . , .


( ) , . ëDamned lies and statistics¨ (ë ¨), . :
ë , , ; . . , - , . , . , , . , , . , , , , ,


. , . , .
. , íí , , ¨ [Best , . ].

, , , . , h- . - , ([Bergstrom ], [StringerííSales-Pardoíí Nunes ]). , . , ( ), , . 7) , , íí , , , , . . íí , : , () ( ). , , , . , , , ( ). [Bird ] [GoldsteinííSpiegelhalter ]. , ( / ),


. , , League Tables ( ) (, ), , . .


, ¨ [GoldsteinííSpiegelhalter , . ].

, . -, , , Thomson Scientific. (, - .) [RossnerííVanEppsííHill ]. , [MehoííYang ]. Google Scholar , , h-, , Google Scholar, ( , , , ). , , . , . , , .
table. íí . .



.

.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/League_


. , . , .
ë , , , , , ¨ [GoldsteinííSpiegelhalter , . ].

, , , , . , . , , ( ) . , , (, -) . , (, , , , ), , .
ë, , , , , , . - " - " íí ; , , "¨ [GoldsteinííSpiegelhalter , " . ].

. ; , , ë¨. , , ,


. ? , , , . , , , , , , , , , . . , , , , [MacdonaldííKam ]. . , , . , , . :
ë, , , , . , , , , . , , , , . , , , , ¨ [GoldsteinííSpiegelhalter , . ].

, , , .


. , . , .





Adler R., The impact of impact factors, IMS Bulletin ( ), no. , . www Amin M., Mabe M., Impact factor: use and abuse, Perspectives in Publishing ( ), íí . www Batista P. D., Campiteli M. G., Kinouchi O., Martinez A. S., Universal behavior of a research productivity index, preprint, , available at: physics/0510142v1. Batista P. D., Campiteli M. G., Kinouchi O., Is it possible to compare researchers with dif ferent íí . www scientific interests?, Scientometrics ( ), no. , Bergstrom C., Eigenfactor: measuring the value and presitige of scholarly journals, College & Research Libraries News ( ), no. . (See also http://www.eigenfactor.org/ methods.pdf.) www Best J., Damned lies and statistics: untangling the numbers from the media, politicians, and activists. University of California Press, Berkeley, . Bird S. et al., Performance indicators: good, bad, and ugly; Report of a working party on performance monitoring in the public ser vices, J. R. Statist. Soc. A ( ), part , íí . www Brooks T., Evidence of complex citer motivations, Journal of the American Society for Information Science ( ), no. , íí . www Carey A. L., Cowling M. G., Taylor P. G., Assessing research in the mathematical sciences, Gazette of the Australian Math Society ( ) no. , íí . www Cozzens S. E. What do citations count? The rhetoric-first model, Scientometrics, ( ), íí no. íí , . www íí . www Egghe L., Theor y and practice of the g-index, Scientometrics ( ), no. , Evidence Report, , The use of bibliometrics to measure research quality in the UK higher education system. (A report produced for the Research Policy Committee of Universities, UK, by Evidence Ltd., a company specializing in research performance analysis and interpretation. Evidence Ltd. has ëstrategic alliance¨ with Thomson Scientific.) http://bookshop.universitiesuk.ac.uk/downloads/bibliometrics.pdf íí Ewing J., Measuring journals, Notices of the AMS ( ), no. , . www Garfield E., Citation indexes for science: A new dimension in documentation through associíí . www ation of ideas, Science ( )( ), , Citation analysis as a tool in journal evaluation, Science ( )( ), íí . www , Why are the impacts of the leading medical journals so similar and yet so dif ferent?, Current Comments, No. , Januar y , . www , Long-term vs. short-term journal impact (part II), The Scientist, ( ) ( ), . www , Agony and the ecstasy--the histor y and meaning of the journal impact factor, presented at the International Congress on Peer Review and Bibliomedical Publication, Chicago, September , . http://garfield.library.upenn.edu/papers/ jifchicago2005.pdf Goldstein H., Spiegelhalter D. J., League tables and their limitations: Statistical issues in comparisons of institutional performance, J. R. Statist. Soc. A ( ), no. , íí . www , www Hall P., Measuring research performance in the mathematical sciences in Australian universities, The Australian Mathematical Society Gazette ( ), no. , íí . www
- .



Hirsch J. E., An index to quantify an individual's scientific research output, Proc Natl Acad íí Sci USA ( ), no. , . www Kinney A. L., National scientific facilities and their science impact on nonbiomedical research, íí Proc Natl Acad Sci USA ( ), no. , . www Lehmann S., Jackson A. D., Lautrup B. E., Measures for measures, Nature ( ), no. , íí . www Macdonald S., Kam J., Aardvark et al.: quality journals and gamesmanship in management íí . www studies, Journal of Information Science ( ), Martin B. R., The use of multiple indicators in the assessment of basic research, Scientometrics íí ( ), no. , . www Martin B. R., Ir vine J., Assessing basic research, Research Policy ( ), íí . www Meho L., Yang K., Impact of data sources on citation counts and rankings of LIS faculty: Web of Science vs. Scopus and Google Scholar, Journal of the American Society for íí Information Science and Technology ( ), no. , . www Molinari J. F., Molinari A., A new methodology for ranking scientific institutions, Scientoíí . www metrics ( ), no. , Monastersky R., The number that's devouring science, Chronicle Higher Ed. ( ), no. . Rossner M., Van Epps H., Hill E., Show me the data, Journal of Cell Biology ( ), íí no. , . www Seglen, P. O., Why the impact factor for journals should not be used for evaluating research, BMJ ( ), . www Sidiropoulos A., Katsaros D., Manolopoulos Y., Generalized h-index for disclosing latent facts in citation network s. V , preprint, , available at cs/0607066v1. Stringer M. J., Sales-Pardo M., Nunes Amaral L. A., Ef fectiveness of journal ranking schemes as a tool for locating information, PLoS ONE ( ) ( ), e . www THOMSON: JOURNAL CITATION REPORTS. http://scientific.thomson.com/products/ jcr/ THOMSON: SELECTION. http://scientific.thomson.com/free/essays/ selectionofmaterial/journalselection/ THOMSON: IMPACT FACTOR. http://scientific.thomson.com/free/essays/ journalcitationreports/impactfactor/ THOMSON: HISTORY. http://scientific.thomson.com/free/essays/citationindexing/ history/ THOMSON: FIFT Y YEARS. http://scientific.thomson.com/free/essays/ citationindexing/50y- citationindexing/

www


Reader's Digest . , : ë , , , ¨. ë ¨, ( .); íí . Philosophy of Science ( ), no. ,
1)


. , . , .
2) - Thomson Scientific, , Thomson . , , , , Scopus, Spires, Google Scholar ( ) Math. Reviews. 400 . . , Math. Reviews . 3 . 3) Thomson Scientific ( .), : í (217); í (177); í (76); í (444); í (96). , 400. , Math. Reviews 1200 , 800 ë¨ ( , Math. Reviews). Zentralblatt . 4) Math. Reviews ( .) 3 400 , . . Math. Reviews . Science Citation Index, , . , 50 % , 25 % , , 12,5 % íí . , , . 5) ( , , , ) , , . -


, . , ( ), , : . , , . [Stringer et al. ]. , -. , , , , , , -. , - . 6) , h-, , , 84 . : (84 )

, 20 % 15 . -


. , . , . 15 : 15

, , . , h- 15, . . 15 15 . 7) [Bergstrom ] , , ë-¨, . , ë¨ . , , . ë¨ , . . J , J . ë¨, Math. Reviews , . [Springer et al. ] , , . . . : ë , , J, "...¨ . "


:
. *
() . (- , ) . , : , , . , , -. , , , . , . ëAre all thy conquests, glories, triumphs, spoils, Shrunk to this little measure¨ William Shakespeare: Julius Caesar, Act III, scene I ëWhat categor y? Minor writer? ...Significant minority writer? Major minor writer? ...never minor major writer? What did he say to you?¨ Brian Friel, : Give Me Your Answer, Do! (p. ) ë , , , : Peter A. Lawrence, Lost in publication: how measurement harms science, Ethics in Science and Environmental Politics ( ), íí . é Inter-Research, . : ë ëLost in Translation¨, , . , , , , ¨. . . . * Department of Zoology, University of Cambridge, Downing Street, Cambridge CB EJ, UK, and MRC Laborator y of Molecular Biology, Hills Road, Cambridge CB QH, UK. Email: pal@mrc-lmb.cam.ac.uk , // ? (. . ). ? ?... ? ? ... , ? ?


. .
. , ... . XV , , , ... . , , , ?... , , , . . , , . ; , , ¨. : I Wish I'd Made You Angr y Earlier: Essays on Science, Scientists, and Humanity

, , , , , . , . . : -, , ; -, , ; -, , , . , ; , íí [Lawrence ]. , , . : , , , , , , -


: . , , PhD PhD: , , . , íí , , , ! , , , . , , , ë ¨ . , , . , , . , , - [Steel at al. ], , , . , ? ? , ? , , . , - , ë¨, , : , - , . , , , , , .


. . , , . , , , . . , ë¨ . , , . . , , , - , ( ). -, , ë ¨ , . , . . , h- [Hirsch ] íí , , , íí . ë ¨ (citation-fishing) ë ¨ (citation-bartering) [Lawrence ]. , íí , , . . , , , , , , , , , . , , . , -


: - , , . , , ( ), . , . (www.dcscience.net). , , - . , , , , , , , . : , [Lawrence , Lawrence , MontgomerieííBirkhead ], , . , , [Lawrence ]. , , . , , h- . , , , [Baron-Cohen , BabcockííLaschever , Lawrence , Symonds et al. ] , , , . , [ETAN ], . : ( ) ë ¨, ( ) ë ¨, ( ) ë , - ¨.


. . , ? , . , , [Keller ]. , , , , ; , , , . , . , . , , , , , , 5 , (CNSRC). , , , , íí , , 3 , 5 , , . , íí , , , - , , , . , , , , . , , , , . ? : . ; ë¨, , ; , , , , . , , , ; , .


:


Babcock S., Laschever S., Women don't ask: negotiation and the gender divide, Princeton University Press, Hoboken, NJ, . Baron-Cohen S., The essential dif ference. Men, women and the extreme male brain, Allen Lane, London, . ETAN (European Technology Assessment Network) on women and science, Science policies in the European Union: promoting excellence through mainstreaming gender equality, European Commission, Brussels, Friel B., Give me your answer, do!, The Galler y Press, Loughcrew, . Hirsch J. E., An index to quantify an individual's scientific research output, Proc Natl Acad íí Sci USA ( ), . Keller L., Uncovering the biodiversity of genetic and reproductive systems: time for a more open approach, Am Nat ( ), íí . íí Lawrence P. A., Rank injustice, Nature ( ), . íí . Lawrence P. A., The politics of publication, Nature ( ), Lawrence P. A., Men, women, and ghosts in science, PLoS Biol ( ), e . www ííR Lawrence P. A., The mismeasurement of science, Curr. Biol ( ), R . Montgomerie B., Birkhead T., A beginner's guide to scientific misconduct, Int Soc Behav Ecol ( ), íí . Perutz M., I wish I'd made you angr y earlier: essays on science, scientists, and humanity, Cold Spring Harbor Laborator y Press, Woodbur y, NY, . Steele C., Butler L., Kingsley D., The publishing imperative: the per vasive influence of publiíí cation metrics, Learned Publishing ( ), . Symonds M. R. E., Gemmell N. J., Braisher T. L., Gorringe K. L., Elgar M. A. Gender dif ferences in publication output: towards an unbiased metric of research performance, PLoS One ( ), e . www


-
*
, Nature, - , , , , . , - . , , . . , -. . , , , , . c - , PLoS ne. , - . , , , .


, , ( ) , , . , , ë-¨ . - .
: Philip Campbell, Escape from the impact factor, Ethics in Science and Environmental Politics ( ), íí . é Inter-Research, . . . * Nature, Crinan Street, London N XW, UK.


- , , .


. . . - íí 32,2. (Nature ( ), ), , Nature (. . . , .), , 89 % - 25 % . íí Nature, ., . . , , . ., . - . . , íí ., (proteome ) . . . íí . 100 . . - , , , , ë¨ . ë¨ ( )? íí , , , , , , , , , , , ,


Proteome íí ( ) . íí . .


. (, ), ë¨. - , . . , , Science. - ISI - Nature Nature , ë ¨. , -. , - , , íí . , , , -, . , Nature, Nature Science , ISI. , , . , . , Nature, , , , , - , . Nature , . , , ë¨ . íí , , ë¨ -. . , , Nature -, , Institute for Scientific Information íí Thomson Scientific (c. ë ¨ . ., . ). íí . . Nature Pubishing Group. íí . .


- -. , , , , . . , ë¨, , , , íí , íí ( ) [Lawrence , Lawrence ]. , , , , . . , : , . . , .


Scientometrics , , . Wikipedia h- , . , , [Lehman et al., ]. , . c . Nature - Nature ( , íí íí ) , . . , ,


. , . , , . , ( ë ¨ ) , (Digital Object Identifier, DOI). , íí , íí , , , , , . , , , , , . , , . íí , , , , , -. íí íí . , ; , . PLoS One, , (the Public Librar y Science, www.plosone.org). , , . , , . , (, . .). íí . .


- , , . , PLoS One , Nature , íí , . íí , . , , ? , arXiv (http: //arxiv.org) . , , , , , . , , , , . , . , . . , , , .


íí . Lawrence P., The politics of publication, Nature ( ), ííR Lawrence P., The mismeasurement of science, Curr Biol ( ), R . Lehmann S., Jackson A. D., Lautrup B. E., Measures for measures, Nature íí . ( ),

, , 20 . íí . .



*
- () - , . , . , ë , ¨. -. -, , , ( íí ) .


- . - ; , , ; , , - ; . - ISI (Thomson Reuters) , . 1), 2), 3), 4) : . - íí , .
: Douglas N. Arnold, Kristine K. Fowler, Nefarious Numbers, Notices of the Ameríí ican Mathematical Society ( ) ( ), . . (http://www. ispras.ru/ru/preprints/archives/prep_22_2010.php). . * íí . (Society for Industrial and Applied Mathematics, SIAM). íí . , , , .


. , , . , - , (, , 90 % ). , . , (, , ), , , . . , - , , , . . 5) , ë - , , , , , ¨. , -, , World Scientific, International Journal of Algebra and Computation (AC): ë- AC , . , .! AC¨. - 1,7 % , . - () - , . , . , ë , ¨ 6) . -. -


. , . -, , , ( íí ) . -. . - 7) , ¨. , . , , . , . 8) Chronicle of Higher Education 9) Wall Street Journal. , - , . , Journal of Gerontology A , ; . Journal of Gerontology A. , , , , . .

NSNS
, -. - ëMathematics, Applied¨ International Journal of Nonlinear Sciíí ences and Numerical Simulation (NSNS). .


, , . . , , , NSNS . -. . ( ) NSNS , , , , , (Journal Citation Report, JCR) ISI. -: Communications on Pure and Applied Mathematics (CPAM) SIAM Review (SIREV), . - , , . CPAM (Courant Institute of Mathematical Sciences), SIREV (Society for Industrial and Applied Mathematics, SIAM) 10) . . . , , , , - . , , , . (Australian Research Council) , . ( (Australian Academy of Science)), ( (Australian Mathematical Society)) 11) . . (Excellence in Research Australia, ERA), ERA (ERA Journal List). -


. , . , ë ¨, : A*: ; A: ; B: , ; C: . ERA , . JCR - ëMathematics, Applied¨. . - . , - . -

. . - . , ERA. , - , - , 95 %. . - A*.


-, , , . 20 % A*; , - 51 % A, 23 % B 17 % C. NSNS, , -, , . ERA A* . -, CPAM SIREV, - A, NSNS B. A B. , NSNS B, ERA; , . , ERA , NSNS , - íí . - .

-
- NSNS , . , NSNS ., ( , ) . . . , , íí . 29 % , -. , , SIREV, , , 12 % , . CPAM , ( , ), 7 % ,


. , . . , , -. , ., , ., , 16 % CPAM , SIREV 8 %. , 71,5 % NSNS , . - ., -, . , íí ., . (,

- . íí . 8,91 3,69 2,8 ë-¨ . íí . 1,27 3,46 10,4

NSNS CPAM SIREV

) 12) , , , , -. , ( - JCR), , -. , - NSNS , . , - CPAM , - SIREV . , , , NSNS . , , -. , . -


- , . . NSNS , 7 % , -. (0,8 %) SIREV (2,4,%) CPAM. . NSNS Journal of Physics: Conference Series. , -, 20 % , -. ? , NSNS . . NSNS Topological Methods in Nonlinear Analysis, (14 %), . ; NSNS. . NSNS, -. . , NSNS, : Journal of Polymer Engineering ( NSNS, Freund), . Chaos, Solitons & Fractals (CS&F) , . , . . CS&F, , NSNS. , , CS&F , NSNS. NSNS , , ; ,


. , . Zeitschrif t fur Naturforschung A. è , , ( Asian Academic Publishers). , NSNS. , , , 70 % , - NSNS.


, , . (Essential Science Indicators), Thomson Reuters, ë , , , ¨. , , , -, ( , ). Journal of Physics: Conference Series, , . , 13) . , , ScienceWatch.com 14) : ë Thomson Scientific, ... Web of Science , ¨. ESI ë íí .¨ (Hottest Research of - ) ë .¨. , , h- ( -


). h- íí ( ) , . . , h- , 35 15) . , , .


, - . . , - . - , . , , , , , ( - ). , - . , , -, . . , , . ? , , . , , . . , , , , -


. , . , .


P. O. Seglen, Why the impact factor of journals should not be used íí for evaluating research, BMJ ( ), . 2) íí J. Ewing, Measuring journals, Notices of the AMS ( ), . 3) R. Golubic, M. Rudes, N. Kovacic, M. Marusic, and A. Marusic, Calculating impact factor: how bibliographical classification of journal items af fects the impact factor of large and small journals, Sci. Eng. Ethics ( ), íí . 4) R. Adler, J. Ewing, P. Taylor, Citation statistics, Statistical Sciences ( ), íí . 5) M. Amin, M. Mabe, Impact factors: use and abuse, Perspectives in Publishing ( ), íí . 6) M. Strathern, Improv" ing Ratings": Audit in the British University System, European Review íí . ( ), 7) S. Macdonaldm, J. Kam, Aardvark et al.: quality journals and gamesmanship in management studies, Journal of Information Science íí . ( ), 8) R. Monastersky, The number that's devouring science, Chronicle of Higher Education ( ). 9) S. Begley, Science journals artfully tr y to boost their rankings, Wall Street Journal, June ,B . 10) íí . SIAM. 11) Australian Research Council, Ranked Journal List Development. http://www.arc.gov.au/era/journal_list_dev.htm. 12) . JCP ëMathematics, Applied¨ 9,5 . 13) , , h- 39, (Nonl. Sci. Letters ( ), ). 14) ScienceWatch.com, April . http://sciencewatch.com/inter/aut/2008/08- apr/08aprHe/. 15) J. Hirsch, An index to quantify an individual's scientific research íí output, PNAS ( ), .
1)


ë¨
. .
. .: , , , íí . . . .: . , , . , íí , . , ëitation statistics¨, ë ¨ . : ë . , , . , , , . , ¨. , , -, ë¨ , . , . . .: : , , .
: . , , ( ), . é ë ¨, . 17 , 50. íí . . . . ., . íí . íí . . . . ., . . íí . .


. . . .: , . , , , , . , : , . , . .



, -, - . : ) íí -; ) íí , ; ) íí , . : , , -, - ( ) . . . í , (%) í (. /.) í , í , , , ,
: http://www.edu.ru/db- mon/mo/Data/d_09/prm406- 2.htm. . .


. . í ( íí ), ( , , ) í ( ( , , ), , ) í Web of Science, ( (, , ). , ) í Web of Science ( Web of Science ( , ), , ) í - Web of Science ( , Web of Science ( , , ) - ; ( , ) ( ) Web of Science) í , , , ,( 150 ), , , ( ), . . í , ,


í , , í () , , . - . . . .






. J. Ewing, Judging Journals, . http://www.ams.org/ewing/Documents/Judgingjournals.pdf . . -, : , ( ). . L. Butler, Modifying publicaton practices in responce to funding formulas, Research Evaluation : ( ), íí . www . J. Ewing, Why the AMS does not provide journal usage statistics . http://www.ams.org/ewing/Documents/NoStatistics- 43.pdf . . . -, -, . íí . www , : ( ), . J. Ewing , Measuring Journals, Notices of the Amer. Math. Soc. íí :( ), . www . . . , . . , : , ( ), íí . www . . . , . . , MathNet.Ru. íí . www , . : ( )( ), è . J. Glaser, G. Laudel, Evaluation without Evaluators: The impact of funding formulae on Australian university research, in: R. Whitley, K. Barker, J. Glaser (Hg.), The Changing Governance of the Sciences: The Advent of Research Evaluation Systems, Yearbook Sociology of the Sciences, , Dordrecht. . Ethics in Science and Environmental Politics : ( ), ESEP theme section: The use and misuse of bibliometric indices in evaluating scholarly performance ( ). http://www.int- res.com/abstracts/esep/v8/n1/ . . . , . , : , : íí ( ), .
, . [ , , ] ( ) (). . . , . - . . http://www.ams.org/ewing/, http:// mathematicsjournals.blogspot.com/

www


. Nature , June ( ). http://www.nature.com/news/specials/metrics/index.html . . , : . . . http://www.strf.ru/material.aspx?CatalogId=221&d_no=38162 . . . , íí . , : ( ),



(Adler Robert) íí (Technion), , , . (Arnold Douglas) íí íí (), . SIAM , , , . (Campbell Philip) íí , Nature. (Lovasz Laslo) íí íí , . , , , , . . (Lawrence Peter A.) íí (), , , . (Taylor Peter) íí (), , , , . íí (-), íí - , .
SIAM íí . . 12 - , (www.siam.org). . 14 . . http://en.wikipedia. org/wiki/Society_for_Industrial_and_Applied_Mathematics. 77 . , , , íí . . www.mathunion.org.


, , , , , . (Fowler Kristine) íí . íí (Ewing John) íí . .

. 30 , (. www.ams.org). Mathematical Reviews, ( . ë ¨).


, (c )
, , ., . . ( ) . . . 60½90 / . . . . . 4,5. ë ¨. , - ., . .
ë ¨, ., . . . ( ) - - . E-mail: biblio@mccme.ru

-

-