Документ взят из кэша поисковой машины. Адрес оригинального документа : http://www.philol.msu.ru/~ref/2014/2014_LiuIn_otzyv_KuznetsovojAA.pdf Дата изменения: Mon Sep 8 19:13:30 2014 Дата индексирования: Sun Apr 10 11:25:09 2016 Кодировка: Поисковые слова: m 31

o{rraurzaJrLr olrrror roro O'r':l,rn Ier11a r, o Ar4ccep'faufin tr4u Jiro <'fnopuecral seolrrorlr4l11.A.Harpogcuotr s xouLer
HCCJIeAOBaHLieM,llOCBqrlleHHLIM flpe3eltTaUUU

W\eiigO-3CTeTHTIeCKI4X nCXaUUii

1910-x rolou B npou3BeAeuurx npo3auKa Il.A. Ilarpogcr. r.i I4ccleAoeasue ocHoBaHo Ha aHanlr3e6onrutot o r{opnyca xpyluoi.i v laattoil npo3br, lz:.4aHsofrnxcare"[bHr{rleii s Poccuu Ao orbe3Aa B 3MI4fpar]I4Io. leMbt IIe noAre)Kul coMIIerJI4lo. Arlya;rsuoc'ru ra:6pat.rt-tofi f{,u uulnleHun MeHTalrblloro KoHTe(c'fa H no:laer.iclBnl

tr4cc,re4ouauue 6a:upyer.cl ua BHy[rr4Ten",tu* *opnyae reoperr4qecKr4x 14 'fpylloB, Sra6trlrorpa$rar Hcl'Opr,rKO-Ju4 r'epa't'yprrLtx K lu4ccepl.aqll ar.,rrovaer. 24g uaraueuosauuii. B nepr:ofi rraBe Et4ccepra\t4n Br,tnBJreHa B cBrr3l, eaNuer.irul.rx 3ThKo-3clelHqecKr.ixngeil eloxu co c.fpyKTypoil nepcouaNa y T-.la rpopcr LToIjJlo obl r()nl'Ko orMerHTb, qro raKatl BblAepxal{lla' nocneAoBarent,t.tocrt) .l.pe.t.bcfo xapaK'lepHa hMctrrro lIJrr IIHca'l'cltcH rlropol.o H p'/Ia, BClloMIIhjl,
^t

HanpnMep,KaK xaJlonarcl Jlee To'lrc'r'oir ua cBOeBorHe AHuu Kapeuuuoii, 6opurleeca c ero xyl(oxecrseuHoli so,refi: I{apeHarroii,3acl'aB}lB yMepe'tblo/t BaloHot\4, ee cl4Ac'11,< Alercecr,r Alercarrlll0tH.{eM", - cra:a,r Pycauor:. "...1)'r'o urrcrrne Ha oMt4rraet vue crryuari,6LtB ir.iiac flyurrulrr,lv, - o'rBe't.fiJt - O,rjrraxrt,r orr cxa3ar KoMV-l.or43cnoax npulretrcfi: ocyrrlec r'rltctr anutLi3 rrpon:tuc71ct lr.A. I lar.pqlcroii, o6.se/tuseunux rr,t r.i ur|LeurlueiiBr,tpaxeHr..i' MacoHcKl.rx ee y6exlennl.i: paccr(a3a , poMaHoB u IlecbMa I I OCJleltOBaTen o llpo'fhBOltoc fat:,Jlet{t,l/tpyt LH rjal eAruHc neprIt,ru [y1'l) J]l..rLtrrofo ]KH3HecTpoeuh'. /.lpyry KaK Halrrelltufie U He

' (tl. H. Torcroi B aocnoMfiHaHurx coBpeMeHHhxo8))? roMax,T. 1. M., 1g55,c.231-232. I 2-x


Z 't'arNe Moxuo 6r,r,lto6tt 3aMe1'r4'l rt ro ltoc.lieAoBa'teloro peaJII43oBaLIt b, ral aBTOpCKarr parlHorlarbl'toc'r'b IIp14Boat4'r ctoxert-roMy cxeMa'fu3My u t|JItAerctl K pr.r3Har(oM r{enbrcoKoro xyAo)Kecf BeHHo ypoBHrr npousneTleuuii. r-o B rperleri uane <rccc rrrrr)i.i cHc tcMrir, o6.rallarouru.r ure cBor.lMnoco6errHoc'r'rrNal.t Blly'fpeHHtlMl1 r..t 3aKoltaMl.i. J'arcuu o6pa:orv, t(eJrr, Hccne/(oBarrHfl- paccMorpet{14e H ur,rrB;reHr4e rrocul)ur tt4t rl() cltMl]()Ju.1('tcl(ot() rrnrrut..te .thct()nca. rlre t (c.6) - ltoct,H ty-t.a, I locl.allJr FrLlc r] err Sa,ItaqH r.uc r,r. pc [r.rcceprarlul J]ort4rlto nbtcrpoeHa 14yilaqHo c.fpyl(rypr4poBaHa, Harrucal{a xopolllHM rr3btr(oM u aKKypaTHo ocfopu,re r.r:,r, oTpa)KaeT I{aqr4TaH Itoc.l.b lrccnelloBa'teJrr,r{Hl_lt,rH ee cBo6oI oe Bjral(crrue o6lxupHr,rrrl ret(ctoBblM MaTepHaJroM. [1pz o6ulcit sr,rcoxoii ouef] Ke /p.lcceprau]414 Herr,3rrHe o'rMcl.rrb HeKo'ropbre ce IIcr(ortc tbr. l). llo-lcpr:r,tx, Iro prA uecl(oJlbl(o3atralrr,q Bl,lx cylt2leuuii co 13neleuzu, u H KoTopoMJho Zrrr, olpcAc:rrcl r,reclo tl. Ilalpo;1cr
cpaBrruBanr4 Flaryro4cxyro,r E.

Maccosofr <6ynr,napHofr>> 6el,rerpucrnre.


ra ro/r coMLlcl]Hc ]ror,rBycMbrcilcrrrbre f{nccepTar':t c'r'aBHr' nbmolll,r 11.M.3oprroia, Ilp14 31'oM IIpH3l'lallat,9'fo HccjIcj(ollaLcJtl,ttnrlcu ycIIcluHo pctuct-ra3aAarla (or/lejru1b :epua S,rraropo/lHofo r4cr{ycc'fBa IJrcBeJr o'r pacxoxu x tolle;ror<> (c. 28) u nnepnbre nor(a3aHbr (r'av xe).3ar.ev lllo 14ur,Br,rpax(ae.r. q-ro BbiBo/rbt yAr.rJreHHe, H.M. 3opnoi.ipa3t\eJt]l^la Ir.A. llr,axona, u Bo3paxae.r Ha :)To cJlcJlyrorquM cyx/lc ucu: aKI lel{'Il4poBallll

3aryr e Balro 'l'o, q fo npr4BneKalro uef grruvarrue qu r.arouteiiny6;ruru> (c. 29). r< eH .{yrraaerc:r, q'ro Lreprbt crtinr, I repeet.lclr Llr,te ll.A. /]r,lxosoii, rar pa: u npuBneKaJtr4 BrruMaJ.lHe uuraloulei, ny6nul(H - Maccouofo lturareJl'. no3Bojrrrt

UMel'lIl0 OTpUqaTCnbllLlC KaqeCTIla C'I'uttI4C-tt4KM nuCaTeJILHl4Ubrr..t

lr.A. lir,rrconoii corLracu'r'r,or c I I.M. 3oproi.i.
l la cc. 36-37 JLro tr4ut,,3alr(Hrr(al jlaHHe. rrpano 6erl re.t.pr1c.l.l Ha cyltlecl.Bo r{t4 ccbrrae'l'crl Ha MHeHlre 9ecTeprolra, onpeAeJlr o le e nHl'epa fypy KaK pocl{o rb, a 6erlerpucrur ltpaBo MacooBor,i lcy;rr,'r'ypr'r a cylrlec'f uoua ue, ecJ|4.,rlo 14n; cLlh.r.ae.r. n 14 carejll,Hl'llI' Koropblx Kacaelct 3To ee BbIcKa3l,IBaH He npLrHaAnexault.jMll t4e, ,,ue,runor,,I,, MaccoBor, r(yJtb'rype ro r(oHtla: (c. pa6oi'c 14 30) h parccMa.l.pr4 uae.f t.e qepl.bi ,x TBopLlec'r'sa, topt,re nbllloArr et o 3a paMKLj 6e_rt_rie.r.przcl.u rrpnd,ru;raxl.r rt Ko xr.i u

nrrcoxofi,'rureparype?
l la c. 38 JIto J4rrr, HpoltHqHo 3aMeqacl, v'r'oM. I(y':rr,Irarr, c.{cjtaJr llrreBLt},l(c t} I-leJrccl'Hyro3anr,tcb o 1'llopqec' lc I lalpoTlcrcoii (r{ol/(a, oLre Bti/lrro, rrecKoJrLr{o rroa:a6;r,;r, ri'fo olta eto pl,irotHra, a 'r'aKxe ot(porll4'l eJtr,c'loBara eMy! oMot.arl |Iy()nul(oBaTr,c'). q'lo 14poHHl 'ly't HeyMecrlla, IloloMy qro JI14qHbre !yvaelcl, Kaqec.t.lla qeroBer(a 14Jrufepalypllbre ,4ocrohtrcrua efo rrpoH3Be,tteH Mofyt' uMe'rb pa3Hr,le tii ()6br,]rrrr oltellKr,r. B I cBITHI(c a nl..ttxy t\).91 tj 1gij111j71CJ AVMaI()1a He t(). I ,H() , u't o lpe6yro'r' rrpl4Jrr.trtul ApyxecKue cBr3u. r.i lla cc. 42-43 Jho l4rrr, 3aMeqac'r o Kpti.t.l4l{c liopo.rune: <

yBreKafcJlt,Hl,lMH cloxe'taMH-

Br,tuh'raribrMH

coMrjerjHr{ )Ke KpHl'HKa ro nonoAy ,''uopqeo.r'Ba Ilar.poacxoii r4Meror trecKrzc ocHoBaHU{, KOTOpbre r43Jroxl.rJrJ,rlro I4sl rje ociropr4Jra AoKa3a,ferbHoM oH a Ha ypoBrie.6. B :rol',r Bbrcl(rBr,r rJ )lt<> Ha cperrlefo Balju I4ns coAep)rr4Tc, oueHr{a xy/loxec'nrcl rtrox) ypoltHr poMaHa _ Kar{uecbMaHcltblcoKoro B JlyrtueMcjryqae
fl ee Ilorlbl fl(t4 (np14llo/lHrrb)) Il14ca'ferl)l rrllly l]btrnr/It1. Kat( Tr,1llHqHa' qpe3Mepr{ar MOJIOAOfO riccjreAoBaTenr aJlr yBneqeHHocrb rrpeAMeroM 14CCIel{OIjaFIHr, B|OIHe trpoct.H.feJrr,Harr, BtlpolreM. cpe/lllefo,

143 I(p14MHIru rtrJ{brx ttoeoctcrz.

I lprare:ly ellle pr/r 3allaJrb,rl.rnbrx nr,rcra:lrnarrur.i Bne/teuur. o6r,rcHreurrx 'r loi,i u.lcucrrlocI r,ro. ; IIa c.48 Jlo tr4rrr' 3aMeqae' ro noBo/ly r{p,Tl.iKa lr. Ko*oHoec*ora: . 6orocr, r]1.o3aecr, JIro tr4rrr, r'reAoloHrra npo6,rel,ry u crenara cJrH[tr(oN4KarefopurrHbrt Br,tBor. l{pr.r'r'z Br)tcKa3aJrMHerrHe, u.r.o llarpo2lcKari l rt: yMeet r _ hca.r. )JL,raJrct.u b flepe/laBa1'bLlnltwrlu anbH oc'rb r-oBoprtrler.0tJ ern lp1vot)i peqH; rrpl,l 31oM Ay aBTOpCKat pcql> B poMallc apcrtaHur,t||c Br)l3blr]:lc.r. l-luxaxoro nporr.lBoperturr 3lleclJHe'1 )'l'o1'Iler{oc'rafoK xapaKlcpeH IJI' JIli1'epa'r'opoB , IleBlrcoKoro ypoBtr'. Iluixe ,rho IZr', o6o6lrlabr.: <...uce fcpor.irrH,o.fc.rarz Barou{'e i.t.^ o.aeu. ltoraHHble a8'topoM B 14pOHHqeCKOM paKypce, t(prl.l.r4KaMu BOC p14HHMaJlticr> Bcepr,e3)) (r'arr,t xe,48). Iiorocs, !l.r().ccltH B l{pt4 rjrtccuoli peuenquu 6lrlo raroe T e/llrHonracHc, 'l o 3 fo BIlna ait topa, Irc yMetoulelo Br.l'.fHo epejla.fb cBoH l.rH'feHufi14. Ila cc. 49-50 JIlo L4,s coo6ulaer, q.ro cyulecrBerrHbr ii crBrar B paccMo'lpellHhLIacjIcllHtl IIarpo21crtoi.i ltpot43outcJt llcripoJiopax, tos lll4llrrt ri I r.{xc1t] cBtr3u c ee rolrqarroii. l{yuae'rcr, q'l'o rreKpoJror'- .rI o fo]. xaHp, B no.r.OpoM runep60:ru:arlrr /loc for-rHcrB rllJlrel crr xaHpoBbrM 3ailaH'.reM,no3ToMy Bptrl] nu ef0 Mo)r{fiocepbe3rio paccruaTpuBaTb Aa HOMI(OHTe(CTe. B B pc:y.rr,l'a're rra c. 56 ,ilo 14nr, 4e.lae r gbnloA, Ltr,o ((lpoBeaeHHoe corroc'fa eHlle UU'reur\uii an'ropa "frresa f]n

yKa3a rrr,rMr.t Br,rlxeaBTopaMH...) (peq6 uAe.t.o M. Ilue r.acBoii,l(. Ba aHor:e,ll. Eax'n'e, o. Man4er'uraMe). 14 Bce 3i'r4 (HacKonH) MoJloAoro ,ccJle,[oBareJl, r.ra orr,lrHI'lx Kpr,rrHKoB MoxHO O6r'rCHurr, er-o s,rrc6rrerrrjocrLro B peAMeT. 2). 13o-r;'r'opt tx, 3t.o Bcl.peqarculHecl tr pa6o.r.c uorrbrl.Krz lepeouelrKt4 3Clerrzqect(o|o ypoBHi xy,rroxecl BeHHr,tx[po].l3llel lcl n i.i c orropoii Ha 3Tr.jrrecKue )reMcHTLrreKora. Bo nne4euuu cBoe coMHeHfie i: flpunii4Lter(Hocrrz rBopqecrBa A. Bep6urlroii x r'aaccosofi nr4Teparype,rho r4rrl ocfroBLrBaer Ha HccreAoBaHr,rz (uoAqepKFry.na upeiiroe r roBa.l.opclBo Bep6rarlxoiz, A.M. l-paveuoii, rolopar nogeo.lrinurefice6e "napaloxcajrsr{o" repeocMbrcJrh r.eopHHo. BeiiHr.rur.epa r.r, rz noneMI-'l3XpOBa'rb oraejrbl-tbrMHnojto)1(cHLlfdMr4 C tltu.jrocodlurzI Iuq]re. 14 :ro, rro
MIleII]. O c.r.aJlo "o'r'paxerrucv npoucxogturlcii ficnxoJlort4qecroi.i nepecrpoiiru xeucroro co3Haul.lr"> 29). (c. q'r'or.ueiiHoe lcr, ljogaropc'r Hc rnJlrclcl feM Kaqecl.nor\4, rlo /(yrraae r(o.r.opoe ncl3Boitret npHqrcnurL nHTeparyprroe npou3Bclter ruc t( Br,rcotr14M o6pa:lqar,r r4ccJIeAoBaTe!'tLI.t lbl. HI

Jll4'l cpa'fypbl, ocllollolloltat atolttr4MtlpH3fraKoM:],l(ccl,llblc'tylrae'f Jrrz reparypHoe vacrQcrBo. A Bo'r' /(ll ucctrerl0Bauui..i no crlxojlo|hH l.i corlnoJlor-14i4 Kar( pa3 MaccoBarrnHTeparypa tBrrel crr qeHl,tocl'blo, TaK r{ar( aaer ocuoBr{ofi uarepual. ]lo :'lo orrl r) xe lre ro3nolrre'r' pr4qlrcJrr'r'r, rrorrylrqpHbrx rruca.r.erei.r K npeAcl'allu'l eJItll\4Hallholla.llbHolz Jit4Tepa'fypbr. l|ocrioJ >Ky trepBl.tqHI).1 .r.aKOM B IlpeJ]cTauuTeJr lte 3c1e |Ij qecKue Ka'Ier.opu bc'f l.l. :laveqaer, qro (onperererrlr bre AocrouHcrBo) co.rnHenula l{a,ree J1x>tr4r'rr' A. Bep6uqxoil (r.al,rxe). liyri,raercl, ql'o 3lecb ,rfuo I4ul HeKpr4.n4qecxr4 orHecracb K lllcKypcy l_r 'IepM14 non of H14 rtcKo'fopbix lzc.fortr1Hr(oB. IIa Il oll4lu qecr(oM lro.;lc Xy/{O}KcC'f I I Llc /IOCIOHIIc'flla lle}l JIHlCpa'l'}pllblX ltp('143Bcltcrrtr.i fl14lleJr}4pyrotc11, a aKllell f hpyrol crr Hl[eoJroll.lr]ecKri Br,lto/urbre /te'larjr.r. /lejreHue xe KptlTr.rK14 rrzl <6ypxya:nyto)) 14(reMoKparr.j qecKylo) ccrogHlrur rr.r HccneAoBarcJrbHe ii Aonxcn oc'raBJrrllb6er per|:rexcrall. I Ia c 50 Jho I4ur, pHIloAHt tl o6o6rtletruc ( flc ul.l MaT H elrr,ubrx>rlbrrJorori orrau tpaH'r'cr, I npl4 3'l'oM qyBcrByr, "qro y Hee ecrb raJlaHT", ,,noHrva:ta' qro raraH.ry 3ToMy He xBaraer lureparypuofr KynbrypLr 14 crpofocrH r ce6e", 3areM c coxajreFrlleM npr4Bo,r]1.r1' xapaKl'cpHcrl{l(y l. crpyne , (crH3r{ocopi lrar Ju.r'r'epat,},pa), 3al cM o1,Mer{ac.r. (upopbi'), a ocylt(ecll,rreHHr,t Bo.lrr,Qratlou l{a:arorr. (/.(aBrrrHM u t,goprrec.f}ry nuca.r.eJibn14ltr,t aocraroqHo no3HTHBtryroouerllry: eMy oKa3arocb /toporo ee HeroBepue K Lrr1cro


"paquona.ttt,ttovy ltoc'r'HXetrulo tnr.r3lH", ", ,,rar,uroarure Heu36e)totoi..t xa'r'ac'r'por.pr,r">.
tr4: scex t.{r'rar B}rAllo, riro rtoptir{aHue]lcer./IaKacaercJr l4.fepa.r.ypHOl Jt r) .reKc].a, noJ'loxj4TelbHr'lc MacTepc'r'Ba fiuca fenbrll4tlbrt4 lcTeTarlecriHxKaqe c-t.B a - u71er.i oTKJrtl r(r4 t ro-co/lepxafeJrb r,rx Mol Hllou,/,toc1.on rIct.BaKoropbtx,oAHaKo, c lonblllaf o f xydoacecntceuH)l/o IteuHocl't,reKcIa. B lov xe pycnc nonbtrKu(noAI{cpxKr.t>:lcL.e.ruqedx<)to 3Tr4qecr}tM rexuT Ilbrcl(a:ir,lBarrr.i fJaBr,rIII (c. 175), noct'uteruroii Nra,.toii e r..r3 lpo:e E. I-Iarpoacr xpll'tttra clohJIo 6t,t ttpotattottoctaIIH'Ib lJIefaHrHocru3aMhlcJra /loKa3aleJIr,clrJa fi Bllcol ('l'av xe). Croaa ,(e Moxr,to orHecrr4 H3Jlt4lurjloro 3Morlr4oHarbnocrt) ((frytrciiutr.4c FreKo'r'opr'lx otteHor(:ur,rpaxcrr14c ret{cIr,r))(c. 100) H Bhtcr{a3 lat rr.l b c <'l-avapa, Kar(u llpe)Klte,olilcqae r na : L'onpai.iuel)tyno) (c. 102), AonylteHHr,reB o'r'Llo cl 414cur3Ho H3llo)KeltIlou reopht.t paar.iKaJl rll bliofo rftel,lur.ll,i'.;va, sroxeHltoi B yc la Jr H'r'epal roli lepourrll, BrrrlJrrry{ri rrpeyucJlHqeHuc. ypl KaK Bce nstcragaHlrl,le3aMeqaHur Hocrif pet(oMclt/(arerrr,Ht.rii xapaxrep u lje yMa,qrtoT qeHllocut4 npoBeAeHt.rofo HccIeAoBatruri. Pa6o'r'a rrBJrlelct caMoclort eJrr,r rbrM, 3alteputeHHbrM uccreAoBaHrjeM, peuaxllr(r4M naxuyrc uayLtHyro npo6"rretry BBeIellrl B HayrtHoe o6paqeulin I'racreAr4r ner,t3yrleHuoro rtr]carem. Pe:yllraur HccneAoBaHfir l4Metol. Teope'I'l4LIeCKOe U [paK'IUqeCKOe :]llaqeuHc. I [y6truxar 1r-rl.tcoo'fBet c'fr]yroi 'r'cl\,tc l-(14cccll.lulrtr4oltI.lot.o 14ccJreJIoBalIH1. An'r'operpepar a/teKBarnooipalKael' ero colepxanhc.


flzccepraqrar , a ee aBrop JLo llsr AocrofiHa flpucyxAeHllt r-rcroltofi crelleuu 1 KaHAr4Aa'ra $zronoruuecKr,rx HayK rre clerlr4rrJrbHocrr40.01.01 - pyccrul jrr,rreparypa.

onnonenr OdraulrartrHrrfi

HayK,crapurufi uayuurrfi corpyAnrx,,{orura KaHAr,rAar $lurororuvecKr.rx 4.I4. Corxexzqnna A.A. Kysueqona, Pyccxoro :apy6exrx :av,.
3aB. OTAeJIaMI{ xyAoxecTBeHHoro

6u6tmorpaSuu
z

u

ny6nuqucrurr4

nl,IreparypHo-

o6urecrseHHo-noJrr{Tr{qecKoroxypHEuIa <<3ualrq>>:

(495) 6992146, Mocraa,yr. Borbrua{Ca4oeax, OOO <3nalao, 123001, 52-38, info@znamlit.ru

.=ffi;a*
lloAnucr yAocrg
frasHnft
NOJII,ITI,IqECKO

'd-T*+HO-XyAOXeCTBeHHOTOlr OoqeCTBeHHO-

rlAi4fr

C.I4. , A.(b.H.npoQ. 9ynpunr.rH